Jim Fletcher’s Open Letter to Brian McLaren

August 19, 2011 at 10:47 AM 4 comments

I received an e-mail from Jan Markell’s ministry (www.olivetreeviews.org) and it included an open letter to Brian McLaren by Jim Fletcher.  Frankly, I could not have said what Fletcher says any better, so I am reprinting it here.  It would be great if this actually finds its way to McLaren and what’s more, it would be better if he actually took the time to consider what Fletcher says.

I’ve also noted that people like McClaren, Warren, and others always exude this sense of sublime serenity, whether it’s on the jacket of one of their books, or in some promotional ad for a conference at which they will be speaking.  However, these appear to be masks because when these same individuals discuss those of us who support Israel, these sublimely serene masks come off to showcase their unharnessed anger.

The attacks on Christian Zionists – people who support Israel for no other reason than because God and His Word says we should – are routinely attacked with a level of vitriol normally reserved for heinous murderers and rapists.  Though I’m very tired of it, I understand the way the world thinks and I also understand that a large part of Christendom thinks the same way as the world.  In that sense then, it is no surprise.

Christian Zionists are persecuted because we value God’s Land and God’s people of Israel.  For me, there are two parts to this equation.  First, I am to support Israel because of God’s promises to Abraham (Genesis 12; 15; 17) and because Paul reiterates that charge to us in his book of Romans.  In truth, a debt of gratitude is owed to the Jewish people, because from them, the Messiah was born into humanity.  Second, though I support Israel because God says I should, I also realize that Jews need the Lord, just as everyone on this planet does.  Because I am not in the position of evangelizing Jews directly – especially those who live in Israel – I support those who do, through prayer and finances.

Because of these two things, it is not at all dichotomous to on one hand fully support Israel as a nation, while on the other hand, support the efforts of those who work with and minister to Jews on a daily basis.  While somewhat connected, these are really two separate issues.  The Land in the Middle East designated Israel is fully God’s Land.  Jerusalem is the center of this world as far as God is concerned.  Since it became once again united under Jewish control shortly after the Six-Day War of 1967, I do not believe that God will allow it to be divided again, for which many leaders today are calling.

When I support Israel, I am supporting God, because both the Land and the Jews there belong to God.  Oh yes, He will take the time to purge the rebels from the Land at some point in the future, just as He did on numerous occasions throughout the Old Testament.  Jude makes us patently aware of this when he tells his readers, “Now I desire to remind you, though you know all things once for all, that the Lord, after saving a people out of the land of Egypt, subsequently destroyed those who did not believe,” (Jude 1:5).

Supporting today’s Israel is – I believe – something that not only pleases the Lord, but it is something He expects all Christians to do.  I believe when we support Israel, the Lord blesses our home and our families.  When we have national leaders who support Israel, God is then able to extend that blessing to our nation.  For me, it really is that simple.

The people of Israel need Jesus.  Those who are Jewish and die without knowing Him, fall into eternity apart from God.  For them, eternal damnation awaits.  In that way, the Jews are no different from Gentiles who die in their sin.

All people need Jesus and the salvation He offers and Jews are no exception.  That is one issue that all Christians need to be involved in, either through direct missionary work, or by supporting those who are on the front lines, working with Jews to help them see the truth.

The other issue is my support of Israel.  I can fully support that nation in spite of the fact that its leaders do not yet know the Lord and unfortunately, some might never come to know Him.  Supporting Israel is a command from God.  I can no sooner not support Israel, than I can not pray.

Israel needs the Christian’s support.  We have the Bible.  We know how things turn out.  We know that from the nation of Israel, God will take for Himself a final Remnant.  We also know that this final Remnant will go into the Millennial Kingdom and enjoy the Promised Land – all of it – as they were meant to enjoy it.  God will do this.  He will bring it about.

Where do you stand with Israel? If you are claiming you can’t support Israel because of their alleged “terrorist” activities, then you are focusing on the wrong thing.  Focus on the Lord.  Focus on what He is doing.  Let Him be the One who deals with Israel and their abominations.  Let God deal with their idolatry.  Ezekiel promises that God will deal with Israel, with wrath poured out (cf. Ezekiel 20:34) and with an outstretched arm.  God will go mano-a-mano with Israel one day.  It’s not for us to condemn them.  It is for us to support them.

Here is what I received from Jan Markell this morning:
*************************************************************************
Note from Jan: Jim Fletcher is right. Friends of Israel today are treated like we have a mental disease. Even within evangelicalism, we are scorned and marginalized. What is our crime? I guess it’s our interpretation of the Bible for we see Israel’s land as God-given, not a piece of property that can be divided up and handed over to terrorists. I have written and spoken on Emergent Church issues for years and have aimed often at one of its leaders, Brian McLaren. Most of those in this stream consider Israel to be an inconvenience at best and dangerous at worst. Sister ministry leader Jim Fletcher expresses my sentiments about McLaren and his followers who claim that friends of Israel are worse than Muslim terrorists. Thanks, Jim. Visit his Web site at the link below for Prophecy Matters.

An Open Letter to Brian McLaren

By Jim Fletcher

 www.prophecymatters.com
www.olivetreeviews.org
August 19, 2011

 Mr. McLaren:

For a long time, I have noticed the disconnect between your seemingly serene, peace/love/justice/mercy persona, and the vitriol with which you discuss Christian Zionists, and what I’d call Bible-believers in general.

From your publicity photos, to your blogs and video links, you project an air of compassion and spiritual healing. Your eminently marketable brand fairly screams Frank Costanza’s famous mantra, “Serenity now!”

Your English degree has served you well as a best-selling author and popular conference speaker. Your provocative book titles, like The Secret Message of Jesus, and A New Kind of Christianity, seem inspired by your friend, Marcus Borg, and reveal your considerable marketing skills. You are skilled at presenting your liberal views to mainstream evangelical audiences.

So it is with dismay that I read a recent blog posting on your Web site that references a letter from Naim Ateek to the Archbishop of Canterbury, Rowan Williams. Ateek makes the following statement, which you indicated that you felt was so important that it needs to be in bold print:

“With candor, the last two groups of extremists, i.e. Jewish and Western Christian Zionists, are a greater threat to us than the extremist Islamists. In fact, these extremists have more military power and clout to uproot all Palestinian presence both Christian and Muslim from our homeland.”

Extremists? Do you seriously believe that Bible-believing Christians (I think you’d call us fundamentalists) are extremists? And to imply that Christian Zionists are more violent than Muslim terrorists is not only an infinite stretch, but it is outright hate-speech–incendiary and violently provocative. It is unacceptable.

Elsewhere in your writings you have referred quite often to Christian Zionists, as in this call to understand:

“The need to confront the terrible, deadly, distorted, yet popular theologies associated with Christian Zionism and deterministic dispensationalism.”

Terrible? Deadly?

You don’t know us, yet you seem very comfortable in your slanders, which tells me a great deal about the state of modern evangelicalism–which you and your friends have successfully infiltrated.

To date, you seem to insulate yourself effectively from those of us you view with such disdain. Since you would (I am assuming here) frown on the word “debate,” I wonder if you’d care to have a public conversation about Christian Zionists, with a Christian Zionist? Please name a date and place convenient for you, or allow us to host you with real hospitality, which you do not, evidently, return in kind.

Mr. McLaren, your tolerance has very visible limits, and I wonder if your followers understand this reality. Your public dislike of Dispensationalists and Christian Zionists is outrageous. It is simply wrong and quite unjust.

It’s time to practice the love and compassion you preach.

As of right now, sir, I view you as the most intolerant Christian leader active in America. Will you repent of your hate-language directed at friends of Israel?

Sincerely and eagerly awaiting your reply,
Jim Fletcher

Entry filed under: 9/11, alienology, Atheism and religion, Communism, Demonic, dispensationalism, Eastern Mysticism, emergent church, Gun Control, Islam, Islamofascism, israel, Judaism, Life in America, Maitreya, new age movement, Posttribulational Rapture, Pretribulational Rapture, Radical Islam, rapture, Religious - Christian - End Times, Religious - Christian - Prophecy, Religious - Christian - Theology, salvation, Satanism, second coming, Sharia Law, Socialism, temple mount, Transhumanism, ufology. Tags: , , , .

More On Rick Perry…for Those Who Are Interested, of Course Mr. Obama Thumbs His Nose at the Law…Once Again

4 Comments Add your own

  • 1. Mary's avatar Mary  |  August 25, 2011 at 9:32 PM

    I believe this “WARRING” of Christian vs. Christian is UNCHRISTIAN. I believe the Lord Jesus Christ is shaking his head at this travesty. He said, “Love thy neighbor,” and I take that literally as His truth. I can’t fathom that we Christians don’t seem to get it.

    I believe supporting Israel us paramount both theologically and politically, It’s the right thing to do for this brave nation. Should God have issue with the people from whom His son issued, He will deal with that and it’s His business. We need to concern ourselves with evil; overcoming it as best we can in every regard. And yes, even look into the evil we perpetuate in the name of Christianity. I can NOT speak for God or His son, Jesus Christ but all on my own, I truly think They shudder and have to be saying to each other, “Forgive them, for they know not what they doeth.”

    Like

    Reply
    • 2. modres's avatar modres  |  August 25, 2011 at 11:35 PM

      Hi Mary,

      I’m not exactly sure what you are saying; whether you are agreeing with Jim Fletcher or you are saying that Jim and others should just let it go with their opinions regarding Brian McClaren and others. What it seems you may be missing is that there is hardly a book in the New Testament that does not deal in some respect with contending for the faith. For instance, in the book of Jude, he tells us very succinctly the following: “I felt the necessity to write to you appealing that you contend earnestly for the faith which was once for all handed down to the saints. For certain persons have crept in unnoticed, those who were long beforehand marked out for this condemnation, ungodly persons who turn the grace of our God into licentiousness and deny our only Master and Lord, Jesus Christ,” (Jude 1:3b-4). Note the words I have emphasized. Jude is telling the his readers that at all costs, we must contend for the faith. What he means by that is that false prophets and teachers crept into the church and have done their best to change the gospel.

      It is absolutely the responsibility of all Christians to ensure that the gospel is never altered in any way. This happened during Jude’s time and it has happened in every generation. It is not that Christians are WARRING against other Christians. The reality seems to be that people like Brian McClaren are simply NOT preaching the biblical gospel. There are an entire group of these types of individuals who have either watered down the gospel, or changed it entirely to mean something other than what it means.

      Paul also makes similar statements, that it is up to Christians to DEFEND the gospel, and not allow it to be changed. To ignore this is a travesty and it eventually leads people down the wrong path, which is ultimately AWAY from God, not TO Him.

      There are many people within the visible Church who are plainly NOT Christians. Jesus Himself warned us that this would be the case in the parable of the wheat and tares (cf. Matthew 13:24-50). No sooner had the Church been born than Satan would be busy throwing tares (unbelievers) in with the wheat (believers). While the tares LOOK like wheat (until they are ready for the harvest), they will NEVER be wheat. They will always BE tares, merely trying to RESEMBLE wheat. Jesus, Paul, Peter and others are very clear about the fact that we are to guard the gospel so that it is not hijacked by unbelievers, who are merely masquerading as believers. This is extremely tragic.

      If we choose to ignore the false gospel of people like Brian McClaren, we are doing a tremendous disservice to Jesus and the average individual who hears that false gospel and starts to believe it. While you and others might ask, “Well how do you know YOUR version of the gospel is the true one and THEIRS is incorrect?” It is simply a matter of comparing everyone’s teachings to Scripture.

      This is one of the things that bothers me about the way the world sees the Church. They group everyone together, never making any kind of a distinction between PROFESSING Christians and AUTHENTIC Christians. People actually believe that the gunman in Norway who slaughtered under 100 people IS a Christian, simply because he SAID he was on his social network page.

      There is very little discernment today. Very little indeed and it is not good. People take whatever they hear that they FEEL is the truth and without even comparing it to the Bible, take it AS truth because of how it makes them feel.

      I agree with you that we are to love our neighbors – absolutely. But tell me, how much would I be loving them if I did nothing while they were being fed lies? If I saw someone trying to con someone out of their hard earned money and I KNEW that they were being conned, am I loving them if I simply walk away? No. If I truly loved them, I would actually have to interfere and try to warn them that what they are hearing is a CON and that the person who is trying to convince them of something is a con artist. An argument might ensue between me and the individual who was trying to con them but I would be doing what I was doing because of love for that person so that they don’t become a victim of that con artist. The con artist would argue that he was not conning them and that I was causing trouble. To an onlooker, it might look like I WAS causing trouble.

      Did Jesus go through His life and NEVER have difficulties with people? Did He never engage in arguments with people, especially the Pharisees? Did He ignore the money changers in the Temple area? No, He actually knotted a rope and used it as a whip, overturning money changer tables in the Temple area because they had made a mockery of God’s sacrificial system. He wanted to correct it.

      I’m sorry Mary, but sometimes, love means that we stand up to error for the sake of the people who are being misled. Just as we as parents discipline our children (because we love them), we contend for the gospel because we love God and we love people. To ignore the error is to actually NOT love our neighbor or God.

      If I’ve misunderstood you, my apologies. It just seems to me that you are saying that we should – at all costs – agree to disagree. When it comes to the truth of the gospel that is being polluted with false teaching, I cannot do that. God’s Word has given me my marching orders and my love for God and my neighbor compels me to call a lie a lie, so that people will not be deceived.

      Again, if I have mistaken your meaning, please forgive me, but I’m not quite sure what you are saying. Thank you for writing.

      Like

      Reply
  • 3. modres's avatar modres  |  August 19, 2011 at 1:46 PM

    It’s because people think Israel is a “terrorist” nation…

    Like

    Reply
  • 4. Silvia DeRuvo's avatar Silvia DeRuvo  |  August 19, 2011 at 11:30 AM

    How does praying for and supporting Israel make me an extremist? I’d love to actually see this debate, although we all know it won’t happen!

    Like

    Reply

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed


Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Our Books on Amazon

Version 1.0.0

Study-Grow-Know Archives

Blog Stats

  • 1,239,855 hits

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 414 other subscribers
Follow StudyGrowKnow on WordPress.com